Questão FC700129
Leia o texto para responder à questão. It has been common in second language teaching to stress the role of interference – that is, the interfering effects of the native language o
Sem classificação
VUNESP · 2025
Leia o texto para responder à questão.
It has been common in second language teaching to stress the role of interference – that is, the interfering effects of the native language on the target (the second) language. It is of course not surprising that this process has been so singled out, for native language interference is surely the most immediately noticeable source of error among second language learners. The saliency of interference has been so strong that some have viewed second language learning as exclusively involving the overcoming of the effects of the native language. It is clear from learning theory that a person will use whatever previous experience he or she has had with language to facilitate the second language learning process. The native language is an obvious set of prior experiences. For example, a French native speaker might say in English, “I am in New York since January,” a perfectly logical transfer of the comparable French sentence “Je suis a New York depuis Janvier.” Because of the negative transfer of the French verb form to English, the French system has, in this case, interfered with the person’s production of a correct English form.
(Brown, D. 1994. Principles of Language Learning and Teaching. Adaptado)
Não só o falante francês citado no texto sofre influência de sua língua materna no uso de tempos verbais em inglês. Também o falante de português comete frequentemente erros devido às diferentes formas como as duas línguas expressam suas noções de tempo. Há erro de interferência do português na frase da alternativa
- I have eaten spoiled meat, and my stomach is aching now.
- I live here in Brazil for just a few months, since the beginning of the year.
- I have sent you that message because I wanted to know about your test results.
- I have made many good friends since I arrived in the new school.
- I arrived just a few days ago, but I already miss you all very much!
Mostrar resposta e comentário
Gabarito
B
Comentário do professor
A frase apresentada evidencia interferência do português: falantes dizem o presente simples para indicar duração, como em «moro aqui há poucos meses». Em inglês, quando a ação começou no passado e continua no presente, exige-se o present perfect ou o present perfect continuous, não o simple present.
Além disso, for e since têm funções distintas: for marca um período ("for just a few months") e since marca um ponto inicial ("since the beginning of the year"). Ambos normalmente aparecem com o present perfect.
Formas corretas seriam, por exemplo: I have lived here in Brazil for just a few months, since the beginning of the year. ou I've been living here in Brazil for just a few months, since the beginning of the year.
Conteúdo do catálogo FC Concursos · Atualizado em